High Court says absence of driving licence does not prove negligence in accident
Tumakuru: The Karnataka High Court has delivered an important ruling in a seven-year-old road accident case, clarifying that the absence of a valid driving licence at the time of an accident does not automatically mean the rider was negligent.
The judgment came in connection with a 2018 accident near Tumakuru, where a motorcyclist’s licence had expired just eight days before the incident. The case pertains to Ranjith, a resident of Honnavalli village, who suffered serious injuries on April 25, 2018, on the Tiptur–Huliyar Road.
He alleged that the accident occurred due to the negligence of another rider, Basavaraj. Seeking compensation, Ranjith approached the Tiptur Motor Accident Claims Tribunal demanding Rs 15 lakh.
On March 23, 2021, the tribunal observed that Basavaraj’s driving licence had expired at the time of the accident and imposed a penalty on him. It directed the insurance company to pay Rs 6,22,295 compensation with 7% interest. Dissatisfied with the amount, Ranjith approached the High Court seeking enhanced compensation.
Justice Umesh Adiga, hearing the appeal, noted that under Section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, a grace period of 30 days is available for renewal of an expired licence. During this window, the licence is considered valid for renewal purposes. Since Basavaraj’s licence had expired only eight days earlier, the court held that penalising him solely on this basis was incorrect.
The judge further clarified that an expired licence cannot be treated as proof of negligence. Negligence must be established independently, and the absence of a valid licence cannot be the sole ground to conclude fault.
Based on the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority’s income chart, the court calculated Ranjith’s monthly income as Rs 12,500, given that he was a farmer.
The High Court awarded an additional Rs 2,79,000 compensation with 6% interest and directed the insurance company to pay the enhanced amount. It also ordered that the deposit made by Basavaraj’s family be returned.
Also Read: Indigo flight cancellations trigger surge in fares, passengers face chaos
